POGIL Publications

Students’ Creative Thinking Skills on Heat Phenomena Using POGIL Learning Model

Showcase of NCWIT Academic Alliance Members: Promising Practices Regarding Admission, Curriculum, Pedagogy, TA Selection, and Undergraduate Research

Impact of Process-Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning on Chemistry Students

Making Sense of Sensemaking: Using the Sensemaking Epistemic Game to Investigate Student Discourse During a Collaborative Gas Law Activity

Reflection on the Use of Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning in Science-focused English Classes

Adaptation and Facilitation of Small Group Activities in an Online Introductory Biology Class

Mentoring beginning teachers in implementing process-oriented guided inquiry learning: An example of an inquiry-based pedagogical approach to teaching science

High impact educational practices: A review of best practices with illustrative examples

Adapting guided inquiry learning worksheets for emergency remote learning

Process-oriented Guided-inquiry Learning at Jackson State University and Tuskegee University

Measuring actual learning versus feeling of learning in response to being actively engaged in the classroom

POGIL in the Classroom: Using Active Learning Strategies to Re-energize Post-tenure Faculty

Reflection on the Use of Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning in Science-focused English Classes

Rethinking Scale: Moving Beyond Numbers to Deep and Lasting Change

A Process-Oriented Guided-Inquiry Learning (POGIL)-Based Curriculum for the Experimental Psychology Laboratory

Non-randomized Trial of POGIL for Improving Students' Academic Achievement in Science Education

Moving a Large-Lecture Organic POGIL Classroom to an Online Setting

Cooperative Learning in Large Sections of Organic Chemistry: Transitioning to POGIL

Students’ Creative Thinking Skills on Heat Phenomena Using POGIL Learning Model

Ptariwi, Rinta Dian, Ashadi Ashadi, Sukarmin Sukarmin, Dewanto Harjunowibowo

This research aimed to analyze the improvement of students' creative thinking skills on the topic of heat and its transfer using the POGIL model. The matter concerning heat and its transfer has some characteristics that enable students to carry out practicum and trigger them to develop their higher-order thinking skills. The method used in this research was pre-experimental with one group pretest-posttest design. A total of 32 seventh grade students at SMPN 1 Jaten Karang Anyar, Central Java, were randomly selected as the participants in this research. To measure the increase in students' creative thinking skills, a multiple-choice test had been developed based on the indicators of creative thinking skills. Based on the results of data analysis, the values of N-gain on the indicators consisting of fluency, flexibility, originality, and elaboration were 0.56, 0.60, 0.46, and 0.53, respectively. Those numbers meant that creative thinking was in the medium category. Further analysis shows that, by using the POGIL model on the topic of heat and its transfer learning, students’ creative thinking skills can be increased, especially on the indicators of fluency and flexibility.

http://ejournal.radenintan.ac.id/index.php/al-biruni/article/view/4629/0

Showcase of NCWIT Academic Alliance Members: Promising Practices Regarding Admission, Curriculum, Pedagogy, TA Selection, and Undergraduate Research

Lewis, Colleen M., Olga Glebova, Amir Kamil, Clif Kussmaul, Briana B. Morrison, and Karie A. Siek

Broadening participation in computing touches every aspect of the undergraduate experience. This special session highlights the initiatives undertaken by NCWIT Academic Alliance members who are working to broaden participation in computing. A mix of 3- minute lightning talks, review of resources, and Q&A will provide attendees opportunities to create connections and grapple with implementation issues at their institution. This special session is a reprise of a well-reviewed session from the NCWIT Summit, and will introduce strategies for admission to major, curriculum, pedagogy, teaching assistant selection, and undergraduate research.

https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3408877.3432587 

Impact of Process-Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning on Chemistry Students

Keller, Aaron Adam

Educating students in science using traditional methods such as lecture and demonstrations is not effective with the majority of students. Alternative methods such as the small-group work method of POGIL (Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning) and inquiry-based laboratory work have been shown to be more effective. In this classroom research study these techniques were employed with students in an effort to improve their understanding of science content. In addition, the reason why traditional methods may be less effective is explored through the lens of the work of Jean Piaget and Anton Lawson. Piaget (1972) enumerated several types of reasoning he collectively called 'formal thought'. This formal reasoning may emerge from concrete reasoning during adolescence. Whether it does or not depends in large part on an individual's experiences. The implications for teaching students who are at a concrete stage of cognitive development were explored through data collected regarding science content comprehension, the use of inquiry-based lab activities, and through interviews with students. Finally, prospects for having a direct impact on students' development of formal reasoning are discussed. The results of this study are that the majority of students in a college-preparatory chemistry classroom are in fact concrete thinkers, they require a specific, learning-cycle approach for effective instruction, and the use of such instruction does not in itself contribute directly to their development of formal reasoning abilities. As a result, the study points toward further work to incorporate elements of explicit instruction in formal reasoning skills. Previous research has demonstrated the value of such instruction both in the science classroom and beyond it and that it is in fact possible to aid most but not all students to attain this level of cognitive development.

https://scholarworks.montana.edu/xmlui/handle/1/13670

Making Sense of Sensemaking: Using the Sensemaking Epistemic Game to Investigate Student Discourse During a Collaborative Gas Law Activity

Hunter ,Kevin H., Jon-Marc G. Rodriguez, and Nicole M. Becker 

Beyond students’ ability to manipulate variables and solve problems, chemistry instructors are also interested in students developing a deeper conceptual understanding of chemistry, that is, engaging in the process of sensemaking. The concept of sensemaking transcends problem-solving and focuses on students recognizing a gap in knowledge and working to construct an explanation that resolves this gap, leading them to “make sense” of a concept. Here, we focus on adapting and applying sensemaking as a framework to analyze three groups of students working through a collaborative gas law activity. The activity was designed around the learning cycle to aid students in constructing the ideal gas law using an interactive simulation. For this analysis, we characterized student discourse using the structural components of the sensemaking epistemic game using a deductive coding scheme. Next, we further analyzed students’ epistemic form by assessing features of the activity and student discourse related to sensemaking: whether the question was framed in a real-world context, the extent of student engagement in robust explanation building, and analysis of written scientific explanations. Our work provides further insight regarding the application and use of the sensemaking framework for analyzing students’ problem solving by providing a framework for inferring the depth with which students engage in the process of sensemaking.

https://pubs.rsc.org/en/content/articlehtml/2021/rp/d0rp00290a

Reflection on the Use of Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning in Science-focused English Classes

Ellinger, James

The Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning (POGIL) framework is a student-centered teaching method that has been used extensively to teach core science content while simultaneously developing process skills such as teamwork, critical thinking, and oral communication. The activities used in this approach follow a learning cycle that begins with exploration of a model, proceeds to concept or term invention, and is followed by application of the newly acquired knowledge. More than 15 years of research has validated the effectiveness of this method for improving student outcomes. The use of POGIL as a mode of instruction in science-focused English courses has not been directly investigated. This paper describes the observations of student engagement with class materials and learning outcomes following introduction of POGIL activities into two courses: a compulsory academic writing course for first year undergraduate students and an elective science-based Content Language and Integrated Learning (CLIL) course taken by first-and second-year undergraduate students at a national university in Japan.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334638771_Reflection_on_the_Use_of_Process_Oriented_Guided_Inquiry_Learning_in_Science-focused_English_Classes

Adaptation and Facilitation of Small Group Activities in an Online Introductory Biology Class

Cafferty, Patrick W. 

In spring 2020, the sudden mid-semester closure of my campus in response to the global COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a rapid transition to emergency online learning. Consequently, I adapted the small group activities and facilitation methods of my face-to-face introductory biology class to a fully online format. During small group activities in the face-to-face classroom, students form teams of two or three and complete paper worksheets that are designed to promote dialogue among teammates, while learning assistants and I circulate around the classroom to provide assistance. Evidence suggests these small group activities are a highly effective form of active learning. Here, I describe how I adapted the content of these paper worksheets for use in my learning management system, how students performed collaborative group work together using videoconferencing software, and how learning assistants and I facilitated this group work in a completely online environment during the spring and summer 2020 semesters. I also discuss the limitations and benefits of online group work. Online group activities present many advantages over use of the same activities in the traditional face-to-face classroom including overcoming the many limitations of the physical classroom space. 

https://www.coursesource.org/courses/adaptation-and-facilitation-of-small-group-activities-in-an-online-introductory-biology?fbclid=IwAR1UA-IZakk8NVcpqpp2R74aHU3caoD1eFBpsgvHx0gmvG18_T6L3ssIdFk

Mentoring beginning teachers in implementing process-oriented guided inquiry learning: An example of an inquiry-based pedagogical approach to teaching science

Sheila S. Qureshi, Adam H. Larson, and Venkat Rao Vishnumolakala

This practical guide helps mentors of new science teachers in both developing their own mentoring skills and providing the essential guidance their trainees need as they navigate the rollercoaster of the first years in the classroom. Offering tried-and-tested strategies based on the best research, it covers the knowledge, skills and understanding every mentor needs and offers practical tools such as lesson plans and feedback guides, observation sheets and examples of dialogue with trainees.

Mentoring Science Teachers in the Secondary School: A Practical Guide (ed. Saima Salehjee), 2021, Routledge. ISBN 9780367023126

High impact educational practices: A review of best practices with illustrative examples

Hill, J. C., Jorgensen, C., Horn, M., & Wilson-Ashworth, H.

Process-Oriented Guided-Inquiry Learning (POGIL) is a team-based teaching technique that originated in chemistry.  Its design, implementation, and efficacy rest upon theories of cognition, likely familiar to readers.  In this chapter, we will provide a brief overview of the theoretical foundations of POGIL, data supporting POGIL as an effective pedagogy, a general description of a POGIL classroom, and four specific case studies of POGIL implementation.  The case studies will include a description of chemistry and biology classrooms (areas with lots of POGIL presence) as well as two psychology classrooms (an area in which POGIL is not traditionally used).  Indeed, this chapter will be one of the first published reports of POGIL in a psychology classroom. Retrieved from the Society for the Teaching of Psychology website: http://teachpsych.org/ebooks/highimpacted 

Adapting guided inquiry learning worksheets for emergency remote learning

Iris Howley

Process-oriented guided inquiry learning (POGIL) is a series of learning activities building on student prior knowledge guiding them to construct their own understanding of new concepts in collaborative roles. This paper aims to illustrate how POGIL worksheets can be adapted for low bandwidth and low-computing environments to accommodate the largest swathe of learners in higher education, as was the case during the switch to emergency remote learning in 2020. Information and Learning Sciences, Vol. 121 No. 7/8, pp. 549-557. https://doi.org/10.1108/ILS-04-2020-0086

ISSN: 2398-5348

Process-oriented Guided-inquiry Learning at Jackson State University and Tuskegee University

Naomi F. Campbell, Melissa S. Reeves, Marilyn Tourné, M. Francis Bridges
Broadening Participation in STEM

Process-oriented guided-inquiry learning (POGIL) is a student-centered instructional strategy to actively engage students in the classroom in promoting content mastery, critical thinking, and process skills. The students organize into groups of three to four, and each group member works collaboratively to construct their understanding as they proceed through the embedded learning cycle in the POGIL activity. Each group member has a specific role and actively engages in the learning process. The roles rotate periodically, and each student has the opportunity to develop essential process skills, such as leadership skills, oral and written communication skills, team-building skills, and information-processing skills. The student groups are self-managed, and the instructor serves as a facilitator of student learning. A POGIL activity typically contains a model that the students deconstruct using a series of guided, exploratory questions. The students develop concepts (concept invention) as the group members reach a valid, consensus conclusion. The students apply their concepts to new problems completing the learning cycle. The authors implemented POGIL instruction in several chemistry courses at Jackson State University and Tuskegee University. They share their initial findings, experiences, and insights gained using a new instructional strategy.

Diversity in Higher Education, Vol. 22, Emerald Publishing Limited, pp. 265-289. https://doi.org/10.1108/S1479-364420190000022012

Measuring actual learning versus feeling of learning in response to being actively engaged in the classroom

Louis Deslauriers, Logan S. McCarty, Kelly Miller, Kristina Callaghan, and Greg Kestin

We compared students’ self-reported perception of learning with their actual learning under controlled conditions in large enrollment introductory college physics courses taught using 1) active instruction (following best practices in the discipline) and 2) passive instruction (lectures by experienced and highly rated instructors). Both groups received identical class content and handouts, students were randomly assigned, and the instructor made no effort to persuade students of the benefit of either method. Students in active classrooms learned more (as would be expected based on prior research), but their perception of learning, while positive, was lower than that of their peers in passive environments. This suggests that attempts to evaluate instruction based on students’ perceptions of learning could inadvertently promote inferior (passive) pedagogical methods. For instance, a superstar lecturer could create such a positive feeling of learning that students would choose those lectures over active learning. Most importantly, these results suggest that when students experience the increased cognitive effort associated with active learning, they initially take that effort to signify poorer learning. That disconnect may have a detrimental effect on students’ motivation, engagement, and ability to self-regulate their own learning. Although students can, on their own, discover the increased value of being actively engaged during a semester-long course, their learning may be impaired during the initial part of the course. We discuss strategies that instructors can use, early in the semester, to improve students’ response to being actively engaged in the classroom.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. 116. 201821936. 10.1073/pnas.1821936116.

POGIL in the Classroom: Using Active Learning Strategies to Re-energize Post-tenure Faculty

Tracey Arnold Murray, Paula Deferico, Christine Anderson and Leigh Johnson

Abstract: Maintaining post-tenure faculty’s enthusiasm for teaching can be difficult for any number of reasons; the most common are comfort with existing teaching methods and a lack of time. However, renewing tenured faculty’s excitement about teaching can be very rewarding, especially for the students in their classrooms. One way to motivate faculty to invest in teaching is to turn the focus from faculty-centered to student-centered learning. As faculty at Capital were getting more information about student learning and achievement gaps in their classrooms, an increasing number of colleagues became interested in using active learning strategies. However, they faced some barriers, including a lack of experience with active learning and the absence of funding to travel to POGIL workshops. To combat these barriers, Capital’s provost agreed to provide the necessary funding for five faculty to travel to a workshop to learn how to implement POGIL in their classrooms. Each post-tenure faculty member who attended the workshop has implemented more POGIL activities in her classes. As a result, we noticed at Capital that as more people on campus begin to implement active learning, the students start to experience POGIL in more than one class. As students repeatedly encounter the POGIL method, a decrease in student resistance and an increase in their preference for classes taught using active methods has been noticed at Capital Univ. We have also observed an increase in our own focus on and excitement about teaching that has reinvigorated our classrooms and our feelings about teaching.

https://www.aacu.org/peerreview/2019/fall/CapitalUniv 

Reflection on the Use of Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning in Science-focused English Classes

James Ellinger

Abstract: The Process Oriented Guided Inquiry Learning (POGIL) framework is a student-centered teaching method that has been used extensively to teach core science content while simultaneously developing process skills such as teamwork, critical thinking, and oral communication. The activities used in this approach follow a learning cycle that begins with exploration of a model, proceeds to concept or term invention, and is followed by application of the newly acquired knowledge. More than 15 years of research has validated the effectiveness of this method for improving student outcomes. The use of POGIL as a mode of instruction in science-focused English courses has not been directly investigated. This paper describes the observations of student engagement with class materials and learning outcomes following introduction of POGIL activities into two courses: a compulsory academic writing course for first year undergraduate students and an elective science-based Content Language and Integrated Learning (CLIL) course taken by first-and second-year undergraduate students at a national university in Japan.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334638771_Reflection_on_the_Use_of_Process_Oriented_Guided_Inquiry_Learning_in_Science-focused_English_Classes

Rethinking Scale: Moving Beyond Numbers to Deep and Lasting Change

Cynthia E. Coburn

Abstract: The issue of “scale” is a key challenge for school reform, yet it remains undertheorized in the literature. Definitions of scale have traditionally restricted its scope, focusing on the expanding number of schools reached by a reform. Such definitions mask the complex challenges of reaching out broadly while simultaneously cultivating the depth of change necessary to support and sustain consequential change. This article draws on a review of theoretical and empirical literature on scale, relevant research on reform implementation, and original research to synthesize and articulate a more multidimensional conceptualization. I develop a conception of scale that has four interrelated dimensions: depth, sustainability, spread, and shift in reform ownership. I then suggest implications of this conceptualization for reform strategy and research design.

https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X032006003

A Process-Oriented Guided-Inquiry Learning (POGIL)-Based Curriculum for the Experimental Psychology Laboratory

Barbara Rumain and Allan Geliebter

Abstract: We implemented NSF-funded computerized Experimental Psychology Laboratories at Touro College and incorporated process-oriented guided-inquiry learning (POGIL). We designed POGIL modules for the labs and conducted workshops for faculty on the implementation of the guided-inquiry approach, including learning teams. Data were collected from students who took experimental psychology with and without using POGIL, to assess the impact of the curriculum materials. Achievement was measured with (a) selected items from the Major Field Achievement Tests (MFAT) and (b) our own assessment instrument. Results indicated that students using the POGIL materials performed significantly better on both achievement tests than students not using them. This is the first demonstration that POGIL led to higher achievement than non-POGIL instruction for experimental psychology. These results are consistent with previous POGIL findings in the field of chemistry.

https://doi.org/10.1177/1475725720905973

Non-randomized Trial of POGIL for Improving Students' Academic Achievement in Science Education

David Agwu Udu, Nmadu Saba John, Chidebe Chijioke Uwaleke, Okechineke Benjamin Chukwunonso, Anudu Adaora Phina, Precious Chisom Attamah

Abstract: This study investigated the effectiveness of process-oriented guided-inquiry learning (POGIL) pedagogy in improving male and female undergraduates’ academic achievement in science education, in comparison with the conventional lecture method. A non-equivalent, control group quasi-experimental design was used to investigate male and female undergraduates' achievement in science education. Data were collected from 85 second-year science education undergraduates and analyzed using mean, standard deviation, and analysis of covariance. The results show that POGIL pedagogy, as opposed to lecture pedagogy, resulted in improved academic achievement in science education (F (1,82) = 26.66, P = .000, ˂ .05). The data provided evidence to suggest that undergraduates that learned by the POGIL method had a greater grasp of content knowledge than their counterpart that learned by the lecture approach, as evidenced by higher mean achievement scores for POGIL undergraduates. There was no significant influence of gender on the undergraduates’ achievement in the POGIL (F (1,37) = .805, P = .375, ˃ .05). The findings of the study have implications for the restructuring of science education teaching environments in the university system by de-emphasizing and discouraging the use of teacher-centered pedagogies and promoting the use of the current student-centered pedagogies for enhancing the undergraduates’ academic achievement. The researchers, therefore, recommend that lecturers should organize science educational environments to support active learning strategies for improved undergraduates’ academic achievement in science education.

DOI: 10.13189/ujer.2020.080927 at http://www.hrpub.org/download/20200830/UJER27-19516565.pdf

Moving a Large-Lecture Organic POGIL Classroom to an Online Setting

Gil Reynders and Suzanne M. Ruder

Abstract: As part of the response to the COVID-19 pandemic in the spring 2020 semester, a large-lecture organic POGIL classroom was moved completely online. Normally the course involved daily group work that was facilitated by undergraduate teaching assistants, and these TAs would also assess student process skills such as critical thinking, information processing, teamwork, and communication. After the move to online instruction, the format of the course dramatically changed. In this communication, we describe the ways in which we attempted to maintain the basic structure of the POGIL classroom in a virtual environment. Changes to the course included the implementation of several online structures to provide students with opportunities to learn in ways that best fit their individual home situations. On the basis of survey data from the students and teaching assistants, we discuss the challenges that these two groups faced, including motivation, organization, and technological issues. We also describe how an online environment requires TAs to play a more active role in encouraging crosstalk between students than a face-to-face setting. Finally, we provide insights into how instructors can address these concerns in future online learning environments, including the use of synchronous and asynchronous activities and changes in assessment practices.

https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jchemed.0c00615

Cooperative Learning in Large Sections of Organic Chemistry: Transitioning to POGIL

Dorian A. Canelas, Jennifer L. Hill, and Robert G. Carden

Abstract: A brief review of recent literature describing cooperative learning in organic chemistry, and the use of POGIL in particular, is presented. A case study of the steps one instructor took to implement the POGIL pedagogy will be outlined along with instructor reflections on the overall experience. Examples of outcomes from experiments comparing cooperative learning sections to lecture sections will be reviewed and expanded. Differences in learning between the participants in the experimental (cooperative learning) and control (lecture format) groups have been found in three key areas: (1) psychological affect variables, (2) development of transferable skills, and (3) self-reported gains in key organic chemistry content areas. Comparison of the two groups in terms of their elucidation of molecular structures from spectroscopy data will be discussed. When compared to the lecture group, students in the cooperative learning group self-reported higher gains in skills, and this was confirmed using a direct measure: performance on free response spectroscopy problems on the final exam. Indeed, the cooperative learning group scored higher than the lecture group on these spectroscopy free response exam problems, and this difference between the scores of the two groups was statistically significant.

DOI: 10.1021/bk-2019-1336.ch012  at https://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/bk-2019-1336.ch012